I've read a lot of hype about an article in the Atlantic by Anne Marie Slaughter.
Yes, I know it's in a major paper and therefore lots of people will comment on it - but why all of the "you quitter"/"you whiner"/"suck it up"/"you just THINK you're a good mother" comments??? That's what I don't get. Judging from the responses coming from many people, I imagine they didn't read the entire article but are instead basing their conclusions off the title she gives it. After all, it's a full seven internet pages, which in internet terms makes it about as finish-able for most people as, say, the Quijote.
I slogged through it, and found much to agree with and much to disagree with. Overall, I liked it because it wasn't another "go get-em, girls, you can do it all if you're just willing to be sleep-deprived enough!" (because as any woman who has tried to have children and a career knows, the success you have at both often depends on how well you can survive sacrificing sleep). One important note that contradicts what many of her critics are saying about her article, she is NOT saying "women can't have it all but should be able to! Whah, whah, life is so unfair to women!"
My favorite of her conclusions is this line:
"Having it all, at least for me, depended almost entirely on what type
of job I had. The flip side is the harder truth: having it all was not possible in many types of jobs, including high government office—at
least not for very long."
Read: if you choose to have children, you will have to make hard choices and many professional options will be closed to you. Be ye warned.
I think it's a perfectly reasonable statement/warning/conclusion.
The statement I quote above sums up why I chose to pursue a career as a professor rather than as a high school teacher (the original plan - and I would have been a miserable failure at it, might I add!). Or a prosecutor (the next option I happened upon - there I would have been a miserable example of burnout, I think). I wanted the flexibility that would allow me to do both, and do them both well.
I have to work hard to do both, and I'm certainly no Melveena McKendrick or Linda Eyre. But I am raising kids who are (so far) reasonably-behaved, respectful, healthy, intelligent, and happy. And I produce students who do things like give me flowers at the end of a term (I almost cried at that, gotta admit), and decide to pursue Spanish minors when I'm done with them.
It makes me happy.
Friday, June 22, 2012
Done!
I think it's funny that I repeatedly post "done!" without ever really being it.
But another term has come and gone. Graded the finals in less than 5 hours. Once the university system opens rosters I'll be able to enter final grades (yeah, I've never been so on top of grading as to BEAT THE REGISTRAR TO READINESS!) and truly be done.
We're celebrating with the Fenwick festival tomorrow....we've been living on dreams of roast corn and funnel cakes for weeks now. Or at least I have.
Ideally in the six remaining weeks of summer I'll finish two dissertation chapters. I'd love if I did more than that, but I'm trying to keep my expectations reasonable.
So much for being done, I guess....at least I got to be done with SOMETHING, even if it was only for a few hours.
But another term has come and gone. Graded the finals in less than 5 hours. Once the university system opens rosters I'll be able to enter final grades (yeah, I've never been so on top of grading as to BEAT THE REGISTRAR TO READINESS!) and truly be done.
We're celebrating with the Fenwick festival tomorrow....we've been living on dreams of roast corn and funnel cakes for weeks now. Or at least I have.
Ideally in the six remaining weeks of summer I'll finish two dissertation chapters. I'd love if I did more than that, but I'm trying to keep my expectations reasonable.
So much for being done, I guess....at least I got to be done with SOMETHING, even if it was only for a few hours.
Tuesday, June 19, 2012
I hope she wins
On my way home from work today I caught the edge of a piece on NPR discussing Caster Semenya. I was fascinated by their discussion of how testosterone levels affect (or don't) different people, given that some are more sensitive to low levels and others are less sensitive to high levels; how there's no particularly good cutoff for what's a "male" level versus a "female" level, leading to some male athletes with very LOW testosterone levels; and how it's interesting that you're not born with a specific testosterone level that then stays relatively constant, but rather that the activities that you engage in can make you produce more/less of it.
FASCINATING!
Here's a good piece on it. And another. And another.
So I'm reeling with a brain soup of the unfairness in this violation of a woman's right to her body (different though it may be from some imagined "normal"), frustration that they're regulating (here read: making them undergo hormone therapy to lower their levels if they want to continue to compete) what is a NATURALLY OCCURRING level for these women simply because of the commonly-held belief that testosterone is a "man thing," and anger at the assumption that if a woman is good at something physical, it must be that she's trying to be like a man and therefore shouldn't be allowed to compete with other women.
In all of that, I googled her. She's an 800 runner. Which of course makes me like her. Of all the track and field races, I think the 800 is particularly brutal, and if you've ever run it, you know why. It's short enough that you're supposed to run freaking fast. And long enough that it hurts like hell to do that.
Which is why it was the only track race I ever enjoyed (though I did the 1600m, the 3200m, and anchored the 4x8, often in the same meet....yeah, 4 miles per meet running track). Go figure. Me and my gluttony for punishment.
Watch some beautiful, powerful, focused running. And hope with me that she wins this summer.
FASCINATING!
Here's a good piece on it. And another. And another.
So I'm reeling with a brain soup of the unfairness in this violation of a woman's right to her body (different though it may be from some imagined "normal"), frustration that they're regulating (here read: making them undergo hormone therapy to lower their levels if they want to continue to compete) what is a NATURALLY OCCURRING level for these women simply because of the commonly-held belief that testosterone is a "man thing," and anger at the assumption that if a woman is good at something physical, it must be that she's trying to be like a man and therefore shouldn't be allowed to compete with other women.
In all of that, I googled her. She's an 800 runner. Which of course makes me like her. Of all the track and field races, I think the 800 is particularly brutal, and if you've ever run it, you know why. It's short enough that you're supposed to run freaking fast. And long enough that it hurts like hell to do that.
Which is why it was the only track race I ever enjoyed (though I did the 1600m, the 3200m, and anchored the 4x8, often in the same meet....yeah, 4 miles per meet running track). Go figure. Me and my gluttony for punishment.
Watch some beautiful, powerful, focused running. And hope with me that she wins this summer.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)