But this time in the public education system.
My 202 students read "La abeja haragana" by Horacio Quiroga today for their literature section. It's a great story, you could do some fun things with it with students who had more language or more literature interest. With mine, all I was going for was the theme of "community helps us all to live a better life." The first thing that I had them do was to get into groups and think of stories with similar themes.
They couldn't come up with any.
Not. One. Single. One.
So I gave them the theme. And mentioned "The Little Red Hen" and "The Ant and the Grasshopper". And asked again.
Still nothing. I thought it was the language barrier. Turns out, of the 56 students, only 5 had heard of either story. (Unless they were just playing stupid, which is entirely possible)
This tells me two things:
1) In the course of a generation, elementary schools have shifted their focus SO MUCH toward proficiency testing that they've failed to give students a basic foundation of literary works to draw from.
2) Students, even when they have a story/theme, struggle with critical thinking-type tasks.
This makes me want to homeschool. Because while there are those who will argue that literature is unimportant or too abstract to merit study, I want my kids to be able to read things and analyze them. Reading a story to find its theme isn't that far from reading a contract to get its "gotcha" clause.
And even if there were no practical application, what's wrong with reading a story that makes you think, "Wow, I'm glad we live in a community. My life is better because I don't have to raise my own sheep to shear their wool, spin and weave it, then sew my clothes, all while raising enough food to subsist on and building a house out of whatever I can find lying around."
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Love my J boy
Yesterday when it was time to get J up and ready for the day I went in to his room to get him up. He had stripped down to just a diaper and was snuggled into a blanket nest that he built in the tent under his bed.
He groggily looked up at me, said "Mine wants be naytid boy. Mine wants fweep," and pulled the covers up over his head.
I blame the fact that when he gets out of the bath I usually say "Hey, naked boy, come over here!" and his tendency to stay awake after he's been settled in bed.
He groggily looked up at me, said "Mine wants be naytid boy. Mine wants fweep," and pulled the covers up over his head.
I blame the fact that when he gets out of the bath I usually say "Hey, naked boy, come over here!" and his tendency to stay awake after he's been settled in bed.
Saturday, February 4, 2012
Why I shouldn't read so much
I'm thinking about reading biographies of prominent LDS women....sort of like my "summer of medieval queens," but with Mormon pioneer women.
These women were, for lack of a more academic word, COOL. They did activist things, they wrote, they studied at universities in the East, they were midwives, they anointed and blessed other women (before such a practice became blasphemous and confined to the temple...WHY?! did we move away from that). I mean, seriously. They were cool.
I was looking for a good biography of Zina Huntington. (Well, her full name was Zina Diantha Huntington Jacobs Smith Young....do those last two names tell you something of how her life ran?) I came across her story when I worked in Special Collections at the BYU library....I organized and indexed her brother Oliver's papers, wherein he continually raved about her exceptional healing abilities and her status as the widow of one prophet and wife of another. Anyway. Joseph Smith asked her to become one of his plural wives. She said no and married Henry Jacobs, who had been courting her. Later, Joseph Smith told her he'd seen a vision of a destroying angel, and that polygamy was a divine principle, etc. She was sealed to him. After he died, she was sealed to Brigham Young (still married to Henry, by the way). Eventually Brigham Young told Henry that he needed to leave Zina alone and go get himself a new wife, that she was sealed to Joseph and, because he's Joseph's proxy, Zina and her children were his (Brigham's...even though they were biologically Henry's). Apparently polyandry didn't fly....just polygyny.
ANYWAY. Was investigating for a biography, stumbled on this quote:
“a successful polygamous wife must regard her husband with indifference, and with no other feeling than that of reverence, for love we regard as a false sentiment; a feeling which should have no existence in polygamy.”
This is coming from a woman who said she had a personal testimony of polygamy as an inspired principle. She actively chose her life. She believed it was right. And for all intents and purposes she seemed to thrive in it - did some really amazingly great leadership things. I guess it worked for her. But how SAD is that quote? It breaks my heart....to some extent for her, but really just for the idea.
This idea is why I'm not okay with polygamy. Is it really not okay to want to love and be loved??
These women were, for lack of a more academic word, COOL. They did activist things, they wrote, they studied at universities in the East, they were midwives, they anointed and blessed other women (before such a practice became blasphemous and confined to the temple...WHY?! did we move away from that). I mean, seriously. They were cool.
I was looking for a good biography of Zina Huntington. (Well, her full name was Zina Diantha Huntington Jacobs Smith Young....do those last two names tell you something of how her life ran?) I came across her story when I worked in Special Collections at the BYU library....I organized and indexed her brother Oliver's papers, wherein he continually raved about her exceptional healing abilities and her status as the widow of one prophet and wife of another. Anyway. Joseph Smith asked her to become one of his plural wives. She said no and married Henry Jacobs, who had been courting her. Later, Joseph Smith told her he'd seen a vision of a destroying angel, and that polygamy was a divine principle, etc. She was sealed to him. After he died, she was sealed to Brigham Young (still married to Henry, by the way). Eventually Brigham Young told Henry that he needed to leave Zina alone and go get himself a new wife, that she was sealed to Joseph and, because he's Joseph's proxy, Zina and her children were his (Brigham's...even though they were biologically Henry's). Apparently polyandry didn't fly....just polygyny.
ANYWAY. Was investigating for a biography, stumbled on this quote:
“a successful polygamous wife must regard her husband with indifference, and with no other feeling than that of reverence, for love we regard as a false sentiment; a feeling which should have no existence in polygamy.”
This is coming from a woman who said she had a personal testimony of polygamy as an inspired principle. She actively chose her life. She believed it was right. And for all intents and purposes she seemed to thrive in it - did some really amazingly great leadership things. I guess it worked for her. But how SAD is that quote? It breaks my heart....to some extent for her, but really just for the idea.
This idea is why I'm not okay with polygamy. Is it really not okay to want to love and be loved??
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)